By Ngoni P Jemwa:
Masvingo-The tragic drowning of school children in a disused swimming pool at Mutare Hartzell School is a painful reminder of the dangers posed by neglected play areas. Playgrounds, sports fields, and recreational spaces are meant to nurture children’s growth, but when left unsafe, they become zones of risk. This incident highlights the urgent need for vigilance and responsibility in safeguarding children both at school and at home. It is a matter not only of moral duty but also of legal responsibility, in which the duty of care must be upheld to protect the most vulnerable members of society.
In the wake of this heart-breaking event, we extend our deepest condolences to the families, teachers, and community members who have lost their beloved Early Childhood Development (ECD) learners. Words cannot fully capture the sorrow of lives cut short so tenderly and innocently. May their souls find eternal rest (requiescat in pace), and may their memory serve as a solemn call to action for all institutions and guardians. The law reminds us through doctrines such as parens patriae that children are entitled to protection, and society must never allow negligence to rob them of their right to life, joy, and safety.
.
Abandoned Facilities: A Hidden Danger for Children
Many schools and communities have abandoned facilities such as disused swimming pools, broken playground equipment, and old construction sites. These places are often left open and accessible to children, who see them as exciting spots to play. Unfortunately, what looks like fun can quickly turn into danger. A swimming pool without water treatment or fencing becomes a trap, while broken swings and rusted slides can cause serious injuries. When adults fail to secure these areas, children are exposed to risks that could easily be prevented.
Children are naturally curious and adventurous. They enjoy exploring new spaces, climbing, and testing their limits. This curiosity, while healthy, makes them more vulnerable in unsafe environments. A neglected playground or abandoned building can seem like a perfect place for adventure, but without supervision or safety measures, accidents are almost certain to happen. Schools and parents must remember that children cannot always judge danger for themselves, so it is the responsibility of adults to protect them.
The tragedy at Mutare Hartzell School, where children drowned in a disused swimming pool, shows how negligence can lead to heartbreaking loss. The pool should have been fenced off, filled in, or properly maintained to prevent access. Instead, it was left open, turning a place meant for recreation into a death trap. This incident is not just about one school—it is a warning to all communities that abandoned facilities must never be ignored. Safety should always come before convenience or cost-cutting.
To prevent such tragedies, schools and homes must take action. Regular inspections, proper fencing, and clear safety rules are essential. Communities should also work together to report unsafe areas and demand accountability from authorities. Protecting children is not optional; it is a duty. By securing abandoned facilities and creating safe play spaces, we can ensure that children grow up in environments that encourage joy and learning, not fear and loss.
Lack of Supervision: A Breach of Duty of Care
In legal terms, schools owe their pupils a duty of care to ensure that the environment in which they learn and play is reasonably safe. This duty extends beyond the classroom into playgrounds, sports fields, and recreational areas. When supervision is absent or inadequate, the institution is in breach of this duty, exposing children to foreseeable risks of harm. The law recognises that children, by their nature, are less capable of appreciating danger and therefore require heightened protection from those entrusted with their welfare.
The responsibility of supervision is not confined to teachers alone. School administrators and governing bodies have a legal obligation to establish policies that guarantee constant monitoring during playtime. Failure to provide trained staff or to enforce safety protocols amounts to negligence. In the event of injury or death, such as the drowning of children in the disused swimming pool at Mutare Hartzell School, liability may attach to the institution for failing to discharge its supervisory duties.
Parents and guardians also carry a parallel duty to protect. While schools assume responsibility during school hours, the law imposes on parents the obligation to ensure that their children are not exposed to hazardous environments at home or in the community. Leaving wells, pools, or dangerous structures unsecured constitutes negligence. The principle of reasonable foreseeability applies: if a risk is obvious and preventable, failure to act is a breach of duty.
Finally, the State and local authorities bear a broader protective duty. Public institutions are expected to regulate and inspect schools, enforce safety standards, and intervene where negligence is evident. The doctrine of parents patriae, the State as guardian of minors, requires government agencies to safeguard children’s rights to life and security. When supervision fails at multiple levels, school, home, and community, the law demands accountability, not only to provide justice for victims but also to prevent future tragedies.
Poor Maintenance: A Continuing Breach of Duty
The principle of duty of care obliges schools and institutions to maintain their facilities in a condition that is reasonably safe for children. When swings are rusted, pavements cracked, and fields left unkempt, this constitutes a clear breach of that duty. In law, such neglect falls under negligentia, the failure to exercise the standard of care that a reasonable person would in similar circumstances. Children, being vulnerable and less capable of recognising hazards, are owed a heightened duty of protection.
Maintenance is not a discretionary act but a legal obligation. The doctrine of res ipsa loquitur “the thing speaks for itself” applies when unsafe conditions are so obvious that negligence can be presumed. A rusted swing that collapses or a cracked pavement that causes a fall are not unforeseeable accidents; they are direct consequences of poor upkeep. The law demands that schools anticipate such risks and act to prevent them, rather than waiting for tragedy to occur.
The responsibility extends beyond the school to governing authorities and local councils. Under the principle of parens patriae, the State assumes the role of guardian for minors, ensuring that institutions under its jurisdiction comply with safety standards. Failure to enforce maintenance regulations or to conduct inspections amounts to culpa in vigilando, fault in supervision. Thus, liability may attach not only to the school but also to the broader system that allowed unsafe conditions to persist.
Parents and guardians also share a duty under culpa in educando, fault in upbringing, when they knowingly allow children to play in hazardous environments without raising concerns or demanding accountability. While schools are primarily responsible during school hours, parents must act as vigilant protectors, ensuring that their children are not exposed to risks in neglected facilities. The law recognises this shared duty to protect, reinforcing that child safety is a collective responsibility.
Ultimately, poor maintenance is not a minor oversight but a serious legal failing. It transforms spaces meant for joy and recreation into zones of danger. The tragic consequences, including injuries and fatalities, are preventable if institutions honour their obligations. By applying principles such as duty of care, res ipsa loquitur, and parens patriae, the law underscores that negligence in maintenance is unacceptable. Protecting children requires proactive measures, consistent inspections, and accountability at every level of authority.
The Importance of Vigilance
Regular Inspections: Schools and homes must treat routine safety checks as a binding obligation under the principle of duty of care. Regular inspections of playgrounds, classrooms, and recreational facilities ensure that hazards such as broken equipment, exposed wiring, or unsafe water sources are identified and eliminated before they cause harm. In legal terms, failure to inspect constitutes culpa in vigilando, fault in supervision, because reasonably foreseeable risks must be addressed proactively.
Safety Policies: Institutions are required to enforce strict safety protocols that protect children from foreseeable dangers. This includes fencing off disused swimming pools, locking hazardous areas, and ensuring adult supervision during playtime. The doctrine of res ipsa loquitur “the thing speaks for itself” applies when unsafe conditions are obvious and yet ignored. By codifying safety measures into policy, schools fulfil their legal and moral duty to safeguard the welfare of minors.
Community Responsibility: Child safety is not the sole duty of schools and parents; it extends to local authorities and the wider community. Under the principle of parens patriae, the State and its agencies act as guardians of children, ensuring that institutions comply with safety standards. Communities must demand accountability, report unsafe conditions, and collaborate with schools to create secure environments. Negligence at any level, individual, institutional, or governmental, constitutes a breach of collective responsibility, and the law requires that all parties act to protect the most vulnerable.
In conclusion, Children deserve safe spaces to learn, play, and grow. The Mutare Hartzell and other incidents tragedy is a wake-up call: negligence in maintaining playgrounds and recreational areas can cost innocent lives. Through prioritising safety, enforcing responsibility, and fostering awareness, we can prevent such heartbreaking incidents and ensure that play remains a joyful, secure part of childhood.
NP Jemwa writes in his own capacity as a development practitioner, child safety guide and an advocacy advisor.
